The recent identification of stolen or stranded assets as another asset class to which the PtP concept can be applied has surfaced a number of new PtP foundations. Already, the PtP Project has issued a case study focusing on one foundation that emerged from this asset class—Kazakhstan’s BOTA Foundation—which came into being out of the confiscated proceeds of a bribe paid to the then-president of this Central Asian country.
Now, however, a new route to the capture of significant resources from illegal activity has come into view: settlements from legal cases in which corporations have been charged with improper, illegal, or negligent behavior.
While such settlements often involve penalty payments to governments, the penalty payments are also often accompanied by settlements in which the offending company agrees to commit resources to help ameliorate a problem similar to one that its behavior helped to perpetuate. Thus, for example, to offset the damage done by the explosion of their Deepwater Horizon drilling rig in the Gulf of Mexico and the subsequent leak of millions of barrels of oil into the surrounding ecosystem, oil giant BP and its drilling partner, Transocean, were required to commit US$20.8 billion for reclamation and recovery efforts in the Gulf region of the United States. Similarly, BNP Parabus paid $8.9 billion in fines and settlement costs for violating U.S. anti-money-laundering laws, with $850 million going to support criminal justice enforcement efforts in the United States.
While these settlement funds are often set up under government auspices, (e.g., the BNP Parabus funds ended up in the hands of the Manhattan District Attorney to finance a new criminal justice grant program), in a number of cases they were used to capitalize private, charitable foundations. Examples of these include the following:
Year founded: 1984
Combined PtP-style endowment amount (committed): $3.8 billion
Amount awarded, 2016: $226.9 million
Net assets as of 2016: $197.7 million (via Annual Report)
Created by the U.S. Congress in 1984, NFWF is the nation’s largest conservation grant-maker, working in all 50 states and U.S. territories. NFWF is an independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, governed by a 30-member Board of Directors approved by the Secretary of the Interior. The Foundation has undertaken more than 16,000 projects through grants to independent environmental organizations of all sizes. During 2016, the Foundation awarded a total of US$226.9 million in grants, and estimates its cumulative conservation impact to more than $3.8 billion since its founding in 1984.
NFWF receives and disburses funds from environmental settlements through three revenue streams or settlement formats. From the point of view of PtP, the key one is the Community Service Payments (CSPs) and Restitution fund disbursed through the Impact-Directed Environmental Accounts (IDEA) program. This program manages a nationwide portfolio of accounts arising from legal and regulatory actions involving natural resources and the environment, with financial commitments topping US$3.8 billion as of 2016. In 2016, the Foundation disbursed $127.4 million in IDEA funds.
NFWF was a major recipient of funds resulting from the settlement paid by BP and Transocean in the Deepwater Horizon case, receiving $2.544 billion, and establishing the Gulf Environmental Benefit Fund to administer these settlement monies. Of the 2016 IDEA fund total noted above, $100.6 million derived from the Deepwater Horizon funds.
Year founded: 1982 (HRF); 1985 (HRIF)
Combined PtP-style endowment amount: $13.5 million
Combined amounts awarded, lifetime: $47 million
Net assets as of 2015: $42,857,709 (via Guidestar)
Both the Hudson River Foundation and its Hudson River Improvement Fund were the result of PtP-style transactions stemming from environmental impact settlements.
The Hudson River Foundation came about as a result of a settlement known as the “Scenic Hudson Decision,” the culmination of a 17-year (1963-1981) legal dispute which defeated Consolidated Edison’s plan to embed the world’s largest pumped storage hydroelectric plant into the face of Storm King Mountain near Cornwall, New York. The sustained, concerted advocacy campaign by civil society actors, including Scenic Hudson and the Hudson River Fishermen’s Association, led to a 1980 settlement accord known as the “Hudson River Peace Treaty.” This agreement cancelled the proposed hydropower plant, mandated that the land become a park, and required Con Ed to donate $12 million to endow a Hudson River Foundation to study the river—in other words, to create a new PtP-type foundation.
In addition to contributing importantly to the conservation of the Hudson River Valley, this settlement, and the foundation it created, had an immense impact on environmental law more generally, establishing the right of citizens to participate in environmental disputes, promoting the emergence of environmental law as a legal specialty, and giving rise to the modern environmental movement.
This 1980 decision also established a precedent of using settlement from river-related legal cases to finance PtP-type foundations supporting environmental improvements. Thus, in 1985 when the State of New York received $1.5 million in fines paid to settle litigation concerning the out-of-state export of Hudson River water by oil tankers it provided these funds to the Hudson River Foundation, which was consequently able to create the Hudson River Improvement Fund, dedicated to supporting projects to enhance public use and enjoyment of the River’s natural, scenic, and cultural resources. This transaction, too, was the result of concerted advocacy by a coalition of civil society groups—including Scenic Hudson, the Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, the Hudson River Fishermen’s Association (now Riverkeeper)—with support from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Building on this core of support, this Improvement Fund has generated resources sufficient to award approximately 854 grants totaling around $7 million.
Year founded: 1977
Combined PtP-style endowment amount: $9.4 million
Amount awarded, lifetime (incl. matching funds): $78 million
Net assets as of 2016: $17.7 million (via Annual Report)
The Virginia Environmental Endowment was established as a result of a US$13.2 million fine levied against Allied Chemical Corporation by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia in February 1977 for polluting the James River with the insecticide Kepone. With the approval of Judge Robert R. Merhige Jr., $8 million of this fine was paid by Allied to fund the creation of the Virginia Environmental Endowment for the purpose of “improving the quality of Virginia’s environment.” Following this initial PtP transaction, VEE received a total of $1.4 million resulting from five additional settlements between 1981 and 1991, allowing the Endowment to expanded its work in Virginia and into the Kanawha River and Ohio River Valleys.
Year founded: 1991
PtP-style endowment amount total: $5.8 million
Amount awarded, lifetime: $6,010,383
Net assets as of 2016: $5,525,260 (via GuideStar)
The Environmental Endowment for New Jersey was initially founded in April 1991 to receive and administer a US$900,000 settlement of a court case brought under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. The Endowment has subsequently received an additional $4.9 million in PtP-style funds resulting from the settlement of five other cases. The Endowment distributes funds from settlements of lawsuits brought to enforce compliance with the federal Clean Water Act; as a result, all projects funded by the Endowment must comply with the related Court Orders and must have a clear and direct link to the specific waters impacted by the underlying cases. The Endowment funds 15 to 20 organizations per year, with the average grant being in the range of $5,000 to $10,000. Since commencing operations in 1992, EENJ has awarded a total of 555 environmental grants totaling over $6 million.
These cases are far from isolated. In fact, U.S. environmental law treats such remediation activity as a matter of policy and has coined a special term for the practice—Supplemental Environmental Projects (SEP). As explained on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency website:
“Most federal actions against businesses or individuals for failure to comply with the environmental laws are resolved through settlement agreements. As part of a settlement, an alleged violator may voluntarily agree to undertake an environmentally beneficial project related to the violation in exchange for mitigation of the penalty to be paid. A Supplement Environmental Project (SEP) furthers EPA’s goal of protecting and enhancing the public health and the environment. It does not include the activities a violator must take to return to compliance with the law.”
Not all SEP funds are used to seed PtP-type charitable foundations, but no one has ever tracked how many have been. More generally, the use of funds from environmental and other enforcement settlements is a relatively new and exciting form of PtP transaction that the Project is exploring. If you are aware of other foundations, endowments, organizations, or funds resulting from such settlement monies—or ongoing efforts or opportunities to direct such funds into a PtP outcome—we are eager to hear from you. Please email the Project at PtP@p-t-p.org.
This is especially important in view of a recent ruling by recently-appointed U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions to terminate U.S. Department of Justice participation in such uses of settlement proceeds.
In January 2017, Center Director Lester Salamon visited Beijing at the invitation of the Asia Foundation Beijing Office to speak to foundation leaders and students at the China Foundation Centre (CFC), China Donor Roundtable (CDR), and the China Global Philanthropy Institute
The PtP Project is pleased to bring you a new report from Project Direct Dr. Lester Salamon from Project Director Dr. Lester Salamon highlighting new insights unveiled at a recent PtP Conference into how the PtP concept can be applied
Media contact: Chelsea Newhouse ___________________ The Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies is proud to announce the launch of Nonprofit Works, a new interactive website providing access to critical data on nonprofit employment, establishments, and wages in the United
Our newest report, Pennsylvania Nonprofits: A Major State Industry, highlights the important role the sector plays in the economic vitality of the state. The report, produced by our Nonprofit Economic Data Project, reveals that the nonprofit sector is not only
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Chelsea Newhouse We are pleased to announce the publication of The BOTA Foundation: A Model for the Safe Return of Stolen Assets?, the first in a series of reports from the Philanthropication thru Privatization
The Center’s first report of 2017, “New York Capital Region Nonprofits: A Major Economic Engine,” produced by our Nonprofit Economic Data Project (NED) in collaboration with the New York Council of Nonprofits, Inc. (NYCON), examines the economic impact and role
We are very happy to announce the publication of a Portuguese translation of Philanthropication thru Privatization: Building Permanent Endowments for the Common Good, Filantropização via Privatização: Garantindo Receitas Permanentes para o Bem Comum. This translation was undertaken and published
Statistics New Zealand has released a new nonprofit institutions satellite account measuring the operations of the nonprofit sector in that country for the year ending in March 2013. You can download the report here. The report finds that the
Center Director Lester Salamon was invited by the United Nations Statistics Division to present the work our Center is doing to advance the international statistical revolution in the measurement and understanding of the third sector during a side event of
The Johns Hopkins International Fellows in Philanthropy Program is a highly-selective program that welcomes one or two researchers from outside the U.S. to spend one or more semesters at our Center to conduct independent research on an aspect of the
Perhaps no quality captures more effectively the distinctive character of nonprofit institutions and related voluntary citizen behavior that is the focus of our Center’s attention than the quality of resilience—the ability to withstand significant shifts in fortunes and challenges and
Two major publications have made important recognition of the contribution of volunteering to well-being and human development and the need for improved information. The elevation of the recognition of the contributions of volunteers to this level of policy discussion, and
We are happy to announce the release by Brookings Institution Press of Center Director Lester Salamon’s latest book, The Resilient Sector Revisited: The New Challenge to Nonprofit America! Published in August, this second edition of The Resilient Sector provides
Statistics Canada has released two new reports drawing on the 2013 General Social Survey (GSS) on Giving, Volunteering, and Participating to profile volunteering and giving in Canada. The first report, “Volunteering and charitable giving in Canada” by Martin Turcotte (English
Ireland is the most recent country to have added questions about volunteering to a national household survey and to generate data about the number of persons that volunteer, the number of hours they dedicated and the types of activity carried
In September, the United Nations will adopt the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), an overarching set of collective objectives for the development of people and the planet that will replace the expiring Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) on January 1, 2016. The
The text of this post is drawn from a report authored by the United Nations Volunteers, which is available for download here. Center Director Lester Salamon, spoke at this event. _________________________ The UN Volunteer programme’s side event to the
The following is a news release from the Third Sector Impact project, a major effort underway in Europe to “understand the scope and scale of the third sector in Europe, its current and potential impact, and the barriers hindering the
This post originally appeared in the June 2015 issue of the International Association for Volunteer Effort’s (IAVE) e-newsletter, ahead of an upcoming webinar presentation to IAVE members about the features of the ILO Manual on June 23. ____________________________________________ Despite
A new article by Center Director Lester Salamon, published today in the May-June edition of The World Financial Review, takes a look at a novel solution to the on-going Greek debt crisis. Rooted in his work exploring a phenomenon he
A number of you have been kind enough to express concern about the health and safety of all of us at the Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies following the reports of violence and looting in Baltimore earlier this
Cameroon became only the third African country to complete a satellite account on nonprofit institutions and volunteering since the 2003 publication of the UN Handbook on Nonprofit Institutions in the System of National Accounts. The only other African countries to
Statistics Norway recently released an updated report on its satellite account on nonprofit institutions (NPIs), resulting from their continued implementation of the UN Handbook on Nonprofit Institutions in the System of National Accounts. For the first time, this report includes